Had some realization stuck in my mind for some time, where among the stuff I have been listening to (at least within a few fringes of electronic music)
where the first few tracks or releases of a project, while some rough edges and imperfections can be noticed in the sound production,
somehow feel rawer and more satisfying to listen to than later releases where a specific workflow and style has been found and while more technically accomplished and other imperfections being ironed out, has lost some if not all of its aliveness in the process of establishing a style (quite ironical in industrial noise to have your workflow likened to assembly line work).
There are multiple factors to account for besides evolution of sound.
Was it just a one time off collab?
If the project name is unknown, maybe it had accomplished players in the scene with a few projects under their belt already?
Reading Discogs releases feels like cheating now, old timers at least had the surprises to discover who in particular is/was behind a project (from insider information and/or rumors).
I was reminded of something in the Agonal Lust interview of WCN, where the duo felt like they said everything that needed to be said within the project. I found it was nice that they were willing to not have the project drag on for longer than it had to.
Which in turn reflects on their way to compartimentize between different projects (Disgusting Sanctum, Coma Detox, Meatpacker, Ros Kott).
On the other hand, having some project last for 10, 20 years and more, picking any two releases within that timeframe, and not see much variery in themes and sound palette, setting differences in production/mastering across eras aside: in that regard, highly prolific projects are at risk of repeating themselves. This can be good if that's what you are into (as you have noticed, I am not. Yes, I am a spoiled youngster.)
Guess I just like variety more and feel all giddy finding a one off project with very few releases with all sounds and tracks that I like (Cicciolina Holocaust, Chazev's Katatonia, Necrophonie)
With that in mind, a few questions to mull out:
1. Among unknown projects, how do you distinguish between newbies looking for a new something, even at the cost of being a copycat, from veterans just exploring some themes with a different sound?
2. When do you feel a project has outlived its usefulness, its freshness so to speak? Are bigger projects, even brands, exempted from that? I do not know many projects willing to change their gear with that aim in mind, even if only incidental.
If you happen to share my 'fetish' of strong, one-off project/collab (be it from newcomers or not) that you feel that the fact it has ended/will not happen again is a good thing, shoot them away!
There's a lot of long running acts that still sound fresh with each release, never losing their charm. GO comes to mind, Grunt, Ramleh etc. A lot of the "classics" have known when to stop it seems. I've recently been re-listening to Mangled Clit and for a project with only 2 tapes and a handful of live shows (so I've heard), it's great. Sal coming back just for the vocals on the final Agonal album is nice ribbon top of the whole thing.