Broken Flag Festival reviews

Started by HongKongGoolagong, May 06, 2012, 07:39:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

GEWALTMONOPOL

I must congratulate The Liminal for the sharp observation on Tommi Keränen being a Grey Wolves rip off. Even, I who like them both, managed to miss that connection.
Först när du blottar strupen ska du få nåd, ditt as...

Jaakko V.

Yeah, what amused me was the comparison between, of all artists, Keränen, Grunt and Grey Wolves '92.

Whether something was simply deemed good or bad or cliché in the opinion of the writer is kind of irrelevant as long as it remains unelaborated and not set in context. People can like what they like.

...although I do find it hilarious that someone would criticize Grunt's vocals for being "ugly", hehe.

heretogo

Quote from: GEWALTMONOPOL on May 16, 2012, 04:51:56 PM
I must congratulate The Liminal for the sharp observation on Tommi Keränen being a Grey Wolves rip off. Even, I who like them both, managed to miss that connection.

I must admit that this comparison beggars belief... Maybe the author confused Tommi's set with somebody elses, that's the only logical explanation I can think of. And for mentioning the horrible Ramleh rock set in the same sentence as Butthole Surfers, Stooges and Neil Young he should be publicly flogged and humiliated. Otherwise the review is fairly reasonable, even if I disagree with some parts of it. But with hundreds of people attending the event, I wonder how he can jump to the conclusion that "... I was almost certainly the only gay person in the audience for the duration of the festival." Highly unlikely, if you ask me.

HongKongGoolagong

Quote from: heretogo on May 16, 2012, 05:25:39 PM
"... I was almost certainly the only gay person in the audience for the duration of the festival." Highly unlikely, if you ask me.

Really ridiculous assertion. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZ2d3h_TgU0

bitewerksMTB

This is funny: "...whilst others thought it was nothing more than juvenile crowd baiting performed by an overweight man drooling onto his tits."

FreakAnimalFinland

Quote from: heretogo on May 16, 2012, 05:25:39 PM
Maybe the author confused Tommi's set with somebody elses, that's the only logical explanation I can think of.

I think only band who could be lumped to "sounds like 92 era GW" (= Punishment LP, that is) would be Con-Dom. And even they have distinctly different styles. Otherwise I can't see that type of material being performed on the fest at all?

But I'm quite sure, that if you're 1) bald 2) finnish - you may have to suffer from certain impression some people like to have about you. I won't complain, since probably one of the major guilty ones for this, haha! But most certainly, if someone is watching to stage and conclusion is "aww, yet another bald finn youngster provocateur making copycat PE" tells a bit about nature of criticism? I mean, in case when there is no youngsters, no provocation, no PE.  But again, I like to warmly remember the golden Finnish noise journalism where big cultural tabloid defined Hijokaidan as great noise and Incapacitants as juvenile power electronics singing about their cocks!

Concerning Grunt show, at least according to my standards, there was no sleaze, there was no XXX, very little of violence or actually not at all (from my perspective). Lyrically or visually. But I guess one can't avoid appearing as greasy thug under conditions, and that is actually very satisfying quality -> If past impressions have been so strongly annoying and sticky, you can't shake them off your brain, it seems some kind of unintentional success!
It's kind of blessing that in genre there is nothing to be achieved beyond personal satisfaction. I'm kind of surprised feedback was as good as it was.
E-mail: fanimal +a+ cfprod,com
MAGAZINE: http://www.special-interests.net
LABEL / DISTRIBUTION: FREAK ANIMAL http://www.nhfastore.net

GEWALTMONOPOL

There's no shame in not knowing or understanding things. There's even less shame in shutting the fuck up about the things you don't know or understand. That's a problem with the internet. Every fool can give themself a platform to put their ignorance on display.

Let The Liminal's shoddy review be his public flogging and humiliation. I was going to comment on "the only gay at the BF fest" but I think Hongkonggoolies Little Britain link summed it up rather well.
Först när du blottar strupen ska du få nåd, ditt as...

HongKongGoolagong

Liminal review despite the author's obvious youth is at least written with genuine passion. It's the Quietus review I really would describe as 'clueless outsider journalism'.

Quite simply, people, this is how you do this stuff.

By the end of their short set I'm grinning like an idiot on Idiot Day

Sharp's performance gives off a weird, hypnotic pull. It's beautiful, man.

By the end of their set I'm left with a previously unfelt urge to wear leather shorts and fist a leopard. It's fun, is what I'm saying.


Why do people write like this? It's an insult to the brain even trying to read this drivel.

GEWALTMONOPOL

Genuine passion isn't enough for me. A start maybe but not the finished article.

The Quietus review is awful.

We're discussing the quality level of reviews now. It's boring.
Först när du blottar strupen ska du få nåd, ditt as...

Zeno Marx

Quote from: HongKongGoolagong on May 17, 2012, 02:02:15 PMWhy do people write like this? It's an insult to the brain even trying to read this drivel.
Journalism classes.  Forever part of that writing culture to colorfully say nothing at all.  Rolling Stone has been doing it for 45 years.  Some people consider it art or champion it as wonderful crazy.  I'd rather read appliance instruction manuals.
"the overindulgent machines were their children"
I only buy vinyl, d00ds.

GEWALTMONOPOL

#85
Unlike The Liminal, The Quietus and in many cases the quite stuffy and very Northern Idwal, here is the man whose blog I do take pleasure in reading.

http://muhmur.blogspot.co.uk/2012/05/lettera-22.html
Först när du blottar strupen ska du få nåd, ditt as...


GEWALTMONOPOL

Tony Wakeford is a genuinely funny and witty bloke. I don't know him personally but some of his posts online has had me crying with laughter. He came swanning up the stairs as I was heading out from the venue and I respectfully stepped aside to make way for his rather ample frame. I have a lot of time for him.
Först när du blottar strupen ska du få nåd, ditt as...

FreakAnimalFinland

There was no chairs at fest. Everybody was standing.
I was standing next to stage, and there, on top of entrance of stage (short stairs) was chair with hand written note saying "Don't touch - Tony Wakefords chair".
I hope to get into position of booking private chair at some noise-fest!
E-mail: fanimal +a+ cfprod,com
MAGAZINE: http://www.special-interests.net
LABEL / DISTRIBUTION: FREAK ANIMAL http://www.nhfastore.net

FreakAnimalFinland

Topic has been cleaned up a bit.
If you want to talk about MMA tattoos: http://www.special-interests.net/forum/index.php?topic=2278.0
If you want to talk about role of provocation in noise & pe: http://www.special-interests.net/forum/index.php?topic=2277.0

Due nature of all themes bleeding over eachother, it may appear very roughly butchered to pieces - what it is. I'm sure the general ideas of each topic are clear.

More links to pictures or live clips, more reviews/comments welcomed here!
E-mail: fanimal +a+ cfprod,com
MAGAZINE: http://www.special-interests.net
LABEL / DISTRIBUTION: FREAK ANIMAL http://www.nhfastore.net