I love the sounds of analogue synths and the kinds of influences that Emeralds obviously demonstrate. But for mine, I think their hype rests more on their position as being in the right scene at the right time than any musical pleasure.
Listening to The Overland Tour tape, there's some nice moments, but the sound itself doesn't seem to have depth. Their side of a split with the appallingly named Sunburned Hand Of The Man is somewhat more abstracted and has a nice, back-of-the-memory skerrick of melodies in it, well structured. But it doesn't really grab me, if you get me.
Forest Fires, to my ears, isn't a bad one, has some nice darker and dronier moments but there's a few lax moments there as well. Ledges is a better release. Two lengthy pieces and two shorter pieces, again with more emphasis on darker and dronier tones. The second, longer track in particular is a nice one to lie on the couch and stare at the ceiling to. The third, also long track is very good, mutating drone, some very nice tones.
All up, they are hit-and-miss acceptable.