I'm not mr. Urban Noise, but I feel he means pretty much the same as I did so...
While many of the contemporary DM is not *bad*, it can be good.
In context of noise, it is almost as if someone starts 90's style harsh noise project, and it sounds like Macronympha "Notes from the underground" with more boosted digital finish. And you can conclude, yep, it is
sort of 90's, but in other hand it is
nothing like 90's. In such case Macronympha or MSNP is almost cheaply used as reference point, but I doubt there are many who live up to level they set at their peak nor give credit to innovations + diversity their discography displays. And certainly failing to capture the 90's harsh noise that was way beyond just "crunchy wall".
Some favorite DM sounds for me are for example
Morgoth 1st mLP:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=clkIcQqk7lw"socially aware" lyrics basically, but dirt on the recording and insane raging vocals hits hard instantly
Autopsy Severed Survival LP
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g5IHWtvU2zosleaze and the slimyness of "clean" bass sound and vocal regurgitation. Song writing by Autopsy very few can match.
Carnage
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9OubX-ZhdIor Dismember
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DsC_eywaO4No band who wanted to get "sunlight sound", got it as dark and putrid as Carnage. New bands trying to replicate Swedish production sound often almost joke compared to early days of that sound emerging.
Immolation
To me this remains best song done by Immolation and iconic song of really dark sounding death metal. Most of technical death metal does not impress me, but here each trick seems to be in service of song, not the other way round.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icwNtcmqj8YPungent Stench
when someone recommends me new death-grind or gore-grind, I can pretty much expect total crap. I'm huge fan of old school grindcore, but all the goreslam, cyber-guttural, computer edited, mall-death metal type of stuff sound so weak compared to things like below, which to me is in every way putrid and reeking of original death smell. Not the sanitized or cinematic version. Pungent Stench - not being always gold - is prime example of the unpredictable and monstrous death metal vibes you barely hear these days.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8son3yX_n34List could go on and on... and as a good reminded, while inserting the youtube link, autoplay started Excoriate track right after Pungent Stench. First comment I see is "2009? It sounds like something straight from the late 80's". Well... Excoriate is pretty good, but if you remove the good vocal sound, especially production is most definitely 2009! What exactly results that there is pretty much no release that manages to sound as good as in old days, can be only speculated.
Also doomier or just slower death metal is something where I can't find bands that would be as good as there used to be. If you go to really slow stuff, it tends to lack riffs. If band got one "gimmick", they tends to follow that one formula and get boring quite quick. I get never tired of slower tracks such as:
Asphyx "Pages in blood"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yBrS-UGAv6UMy Dying Bride "Symphonaire Infernus et Spera Empyrium"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVHD4q0Z-osEach linked thing has probably element that bands themselves, and perhaps also listener has feeling that they are somehow odd, that there is plenty of things to "correct", to make it sound good. Yet when you make those corrections, they would probably not sound as good anymore. All the really putrid sounding stuff emerged to be so. Possibilities where highly limited and spontaneous recording situation gave more to result than being specific product. Most bands those days would give many surprises, while now, a lot of material certainly is following narrow templates very tightly.
( When I think of typical contemporary death metal I tend to think something like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96NjL0d4vvAOf course it's barely accurate, only presents one side of genre, it is the type of stuff what makes death metal sound more slapstick humor than needed to be. Equally little I am interested in slick melodic DM)