Live show reports / comments

Started by FreakAnimalFinland, July 25, 2011, 09:35:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

burdizzo1

SPK at Wroclaw? Hmmm. For me it was OK, at the very best. Certainly wouldn't be rushing to buy any of the new music, and the inclusion of a few old tracks at the beginning of the set was the most welcome bit. I'm not fussed by the AI projections, one way or the other. They do get a bit tiresome, but I can't say I found them seriously offensive.

Something about the whole festival, though, seemed a bit unfocused, like they were trying to cover too many bases - all the way from neo-folk to p.e., and everything in between. Did enjoy the Unruh & Meat Meat, Flint Glass & Ah Cama-Sotz, Apoptose, Control and Pffft..., but most of the rest could take or leave. Ka-Spel looked like he didn't want to be there at all, and Crash Course In Science - why were they even there?! I know some reckon there's not enough EBM-type sounds at it compared to former times, but I'm not so sure such a broad range can work. With two nights it should be possible to have kindred spirits together.

Anyway, at least it exists, and fair play to them for organising it. There's fewer and fewer festivals of this sort now, and did I hear rumours that the TT festival was the last one? Regrettably, I've never been to that (bad time of the year), but it always seems to have a good line-up.

Balor/SS1535

Quote from: burdizzo1 on November 15, 2026, 08:28:25 PMSPK at Wroclaw? Hmmm. For me it was OK, at the very best. Certainly wouldn't be rushing to buy any of the new music, and the inclusion of a few old tracks at the beginning of the set was the most welcome bit. I'm not fussed by the AI projections, one way or the other. They do get a bit tiresome, but I can't say I found them seriously offensive.

Something about the whole festival, though, seemed a bit unfocused, like they were trying to cover too many bases - all the way from neo-folk to p.e., and everything in between. Did enjoy the Unruh & Meat Meat, Flint Glass & Ah Cama-Sotz, Apoptose, Control and Pffft..., but most of the rest could take or leave. Ka-Spel looked like he didn't want to be there at all, and Crash Course In Science - why were they even there?! I know some reckon there's not enough EBM-type sounds at it compared to former times, but I'm not so sure such a broad range can work. With two nights it should be possible to have kindred spirits together.

Anyway, at least it exists, and fair play to them for organising it. There's fewer and fewer festivals of this sort now, and did I hear rumours that the TT festival was the last one? Regrettably, I've never been to that (bad time of the year), but it always seems to have a good line-up.

Did Pffft live up to the hype that built up after the show last year?
You wanna know what FFH is about? Well, it's not about "fun"! "Damn, dude, chill."

burdizzo1

Quote from: Balor/SS1535 on November 15, 2026, 08:43:43 PM
Quote from: burdizzo1 on November 15, 2026, 08:28:25 PMSPK at Wroclaw? Hmmm. For me it was OK, at the very best. Certainly wouldn't be rushing to buy any of the new music, and the inclusion of a few old tracks at the beginning of the set was the most welcome bit. I'm not fussed by the AI projections, one way or the other. They do get a bit tiresome, but I can't say I found them seriously offensive.

Something about the whole festival, though, seemed a bit unfocused, like they were trying to cover too many bases - all the way from neo-folk to p.e., and everything in between. Did enjoy the Unruh & Meat Meat, Flint Glass & Ah Cama-Sotz, Apoptose, Control and Pffft..., but most of the rest could take or leave. Ka-Spel looked like he didn't want to be there at all, and Crash Course In Science - why were they even there?! I know some reckon there's not enough EBM-type sounds at it compared to former times, but I'm not so sure such a broad range can work. With two nights it should be possible to have kindred spirits together.

Anyway, at least it exists, and fair play to them for organising it. There's fewer and fewer festivals of this sort now, and did I hear rumours that the TT festival was the last one? Regrettably, I've never been to that (bad time of the year), but it always seems to have a good line-up.

Did Pffft live up to the hype that built up after the show last year?

Wasn't there last year, so missed the hype. He was on pretty much first on on the Friday, a slot which I suppose doesn't suggest that much 'hype'? Anyway, he was pounding a metal chute, and some jerry cans, and hammering the ground with a stake-driver. Probably the most genuinely 'industrial' sounds of the weekend! I enjoyed it - noisy and sometimes nicely monotonous, and set a good austere atmosphere!

Balor/SS1535

Quote from: burdizzo1 on November 15, 2026, 09:06:30 PM
Quote from: Balor/SS1535 on November 15, 2026, 08:43:43 PM
Quote from: burdizzo1 on November 15, 2026, 08:28:25 PMSPK at Wroclaw? Hmmm. For me it was OK, at the very best. Certainly wouldn't be rushing to buy any of the new music, and the inclusion of a few old tracks at the beginning of the set was the most welcome bit. I'm not fussed by the AI projections, one way or the other. They do get a bit tiresome, but I can't say I found them seriously offensive.

Something about the whole festival, though, seemed a bit unfocused, like they were trying to cover too many bases - all the way from neo-folk to p.e., and everything in between. Did enjoy the Unruh & Meat Meat, Flint Glass & Ah Cama-Sotz, Apoptose, Control and Pffft..., but most of the rest could take or leave. Ka-Spel looked like he didn't want to be there at all, and Crash Course In Science - why were they even there?! I know some reckon there's not enough EBM-type sounds at it compared to former times, but I'm not so sure such a broad range can work. With two nights it should be possible to have kindred spirits together.

Anyway, at least it exists, and fair play to them for organising it. There's fewer and fewer festivals of this sort now, and did I hear rumours that the TT festival was the last one? Regrettably, I've never been to that (bad time of the year), but it always seems to have a good line-up.

Did Pffft live up to the hype that built up after the show last year?

Wasn't there last year, so missed the hype. He was on pretty much first on on the Friday, a slot which I suppose doesn't suggest that much 'hype'? Anyway, he was pounding a metal chute, and some jerry cans, and hammering the ground with a stake-driver. Probably the most genuinely 'industrial' sounds of the weekend! I enjoyed it - noisy and sometimes nicely monotonous, and set a good austere atmosphere!

He seemed to have made a big impression last year from the people that I spoke with---though for pretty much exactly the same reasons you list here, so I guess he performed as expected!
You wanna know what FFH is about? Well, it's not about "fun"! "Damn, dude, chill."

impulse manslaughter

Went to see Wolf Eyes last month. It was actually a nice show with Young taking the lead and Olson following. Last time I saw them I got a saxophone overdose from Olson and didn't really like their show. This was more balanced. I've been following them since the first EU-tour and saw them in different incarnations since. Young/Dilloway was a perfect duo, a few years later with Connelly they sold out a pretty large venue and it felt like going to a rockshow. Then Olson was slowly incorporating more psych influences and I lost interest.

Saw Control perform for the first time a few weeks ago. Liked most of the sounds and it was well thought out with a good eye for dynamics, but i was missing a raw edge. It was all a bit too uhhh controlled. Kryptogen Rundfunk also performed and I really enjoyed his balanced set of layered industrial sounds getting from pretty ambient to noisy in the end. My favorite set of the evening. The Law Rah Collective brought a nice analog synth and used it to play long minimal tracks blending into each other. Felt like someone was trying out a new device at home instead of a performance.

2nd edition of my own festival (Dead Mind) went really well. Just a few tickets short of a sold out first day with Rudolf Eber, the Haters and Ernst Bonis (82 year old pioneer of electronic music performing a quadrophonic piece live) as personal highlights. Only show that was a disappointment for me was Wanderwelle with an hour of minimal ambient. would've been better with visuals or more variation. On the second day Kazumoto Endo played a perfect harsh noise set. Really loud and dynamic. Great way to end the weekend.
 


impulse manslaughter

Quote from: Nadir on November 15, 2026, 04:52:46 PMEven a week later I still can't make any sense of the SPK/SPKtR show at Wroclaw Industrial... Despite any efforts to understand where they were coming from, I am convinced now that they totally lost it. In the end I stood there and hour and a half. Half of the time there was nothing playing due to "technical problems" (how is that even possible when it seemed mostly playback?), the other half "something" was playing, but could you call it music?

Essentially we got an hour of AI brainrot shoved down our throats. The set up at first seemed promising and the venue was (almost uncomfortably) packed, eyes peeled at a large cage that was put in the middle of the stage, with a mysterious shrouded object in the middle. Then the music started playing -- some kind of dubstep beat? I was already extremely sceptical. Then the AI visuals just kept getting worse, but you couldn't look past them as they were projected onto a canvas hung INFRONT of the stage. Couldn't even see the real humans performing without watching this AI bullshit. It felt like that scene in A Clockwork Orange...

Eventually it was obvious that the whole thing was just one big joke. Graeme sitting behind a computer with AI generated pop song playing full volume while Robert Revell -- I kid you not -- was PRETENDING to play the guitar or bass. Seriously he was pretending to hit the strings but with a closer look you saw he was just playing in the air. I missed the Robert Revell solo show the day before because since I already saw him at TT (and not very impressed) I used the time to get myself dinner. Apperantly his show there wasn't great either as he called it a quits after about 25 minutes. When with SPK he started windmill headbanging to absolute atrocities of blass beats, I just couldn't help but laugh out loud!

Anyway I tried to make sense of the show: maybe they were intentionally trying to achieve the worst possible sound? Maybe they tried to make a statement about the current state of music with AI taking over? Maybe they were trying to find a way to shock, disgust an audience that is already used to harsh industrial music? Were they generating AI music live as some sort of live prompting experiment? Were they going to put out a statement? In the end any attempt to understand this mess just fell flat when I found out that they officially released some of this AI slop music and videos on YouTube even prior to the show.

Sorry for this rant but I just had to get it off my chest somehow. Can anyone make sense of this? Because I can't, I am just really confused.

P.S. the "mysterious shrouded object" turned out to be a made in China robot who's battery died after one minute of activation and just fell on the floor to lie there for the rest of the show. (I am actually laughing out loud writing this.)

SPKtR is playing half an hour away from me in December but this sounds like total garbage. Why would someone piss on his own legacy like this..?

re:evolution

Quote from: impulse manslaughter on Today at 03:05:03 PM
Quote from: Nadir on November 15, 2026, 04:52:46 PMEven a week later I still can't make any sense of the SPK/SPKtR show at Wroclaw Industrial... Despite any efforts to understand where they were coming from, I am convinced now that they totally lost it. In the end I stood there and hour and a half. Half of the time there was nothing playing due to "technical problems" (how is that even possible when it seemed mostly playback?), the other half "something" was playing, but could you call it music?

Essentially we got an hour of AI brainrot shoved down our throats. The set up at first seemed promising and the venue was (almost uncomfortably) packed, eyes peeled at a large cage that was put in the middle of the stage, with a mysterious shrouded object in the middle. Then the music started playing -- some kind of dubstep beat? I was already extremely sceptical. Then the AI visuals just kept getting worse, but you couldn't look past them as they were projected onto a canvas hung INFRONT of the stage. Couldn't even see the real humans performing without watching this AI bullshit. It felt like that scene in A Clockwork Orange...

Eventually it was obvious that the whole thing was just one big joke. Graeme sitting behind a computer with AI generated pop song playing full volume while Robert Revell -- I kid you not -- was PRETENDING to play the guitar or bass. Seriously he was pretending to hit the strings but with a closer look you saw he was just playing in the air. I missed the Robert Revell solo show the day before because since I already saw him at TT (and not very impressed) I used the time to get myself dinner. Apperantly his show there wasn't great either as he called it a quits after about 25 minutes. When with SPK he started windmill headbanging to absolute atrocities of blass beats, I just couldn't help but laugh out loud!

Anyway I tried to make sense of the show: maybe they were intentionally trying to achieve the worst possible sound? Maybe they tried to make a statement about the current state of music with AI taking over? Maybe they were trying to find a way to shock, disgust an audience that is already used to harsh industrial music? Were they generating AI music live as some sort of live prompting experiment? Were they going to put out a statement? In the end any attempt to understand this mess just fell flat when I found out that they officially released some of this AI slop music and videos on YouTube even prior to the show.

Sorry for this rant but I just had to get it off my chest somehow. Can anyone make sense of this? Because I can't, I am just really confused.

P.S. the "mysterious shrouded object" turned out to be a made in China robot who's battery died after one minute of activation and just fell on the floor to lie there for the rest of the show. (I am actually laughing out loud writing this.)

SPKtR is playing half an hour away from me in December but this sounds like total garbage. Why would someone piss on his own legacy like this..?


Didn't the 'pissing on legacy' already happen with the synth-pop era? I do note that Graeme has said more recently that the 'synth-pop' direction was a result of needing money for family obligations, which I appreciate. But what I did take issue with was his follow on criticism about opinionated SPK 'fans' not liking the new direction. Having a intellectually based and conceptually strong project which then reoriented to a fully commercial market would not be of interest to most original fans. It is then completely disingenuous for him to criticise 'fans' when the reorientation was about money and not artistic intent. Like someone else said: 'you can't have it both ways'.

As I have send on other social media posts, Graeme can do exactly what he wants with with SPKtr - and the results will be judged on merit accordingly. From what I have seen and heard to date it is nothing which I have interest in. Nor does it reflects the legacy of the first phase of the project. Nor does it even much relevance to the current underground. What I then am perplexed about is the number of people of seemingly loving the output of the reactivated project - or even just hyped to see SPK live, and not viewing the new material with a critical eye. Each to their own I guess. 



noise receptor: sound with impact - analysing the abstract
http://noisereceptor.wordpress.com/
http://www.noisereceptor.bigcartel.com

spectrum magazine archive: ambient / industrial / experimental / power electronics / neo-folk music culture magazine
http://spectrummagarchive.wordpress.com/