Quote from: Euro Trash Bazooka on June 24, 2018, 10:09:26 PM
I can't accept that some people just "know better", like the ones who'd rather buy some of the records Holy Ghost mentioned.
You can't look weak by current nonsensical standards (they seem nonsensical to me at least) so you'd rather own 50 4th rate bestialnecrotrvegrimkvlt war metal picture discs rather than know all good Maiden and Priest's albums by heart.
I accept that some people know better - or are strong minded in being in such conclusion. Especially within BM, it would be crucial.
Yet, from perspective I'm looking from, I don't see anywhere standard that metalheads would be hoarding and boasting with war metal picture discs, but rather everybody listening everything else but
bestialnecrotrvegrimkvlt. It is likely person you talk to will blatantly say they just listen Iron Maiden and Danzig from youtube and that's about it. Regardless how rough labels or bands they operate. There is no shortage of people who sing along any Iron Maiden song, I can tell you that.
I have seen people make very broad generalization about Special Interests Forum, as hang-out place of alt-right noise slobs. How much truth is in that, seems to be purely based on observers own hang-ups. Focusing on revolving with handful of messages/topics one dislikes, unable to move to things you do. Of course you see what you see. If some things, like lesser appreciated NWN titles are pressed 250 and don't even sell out, crowd that collects that stuff is unlikely such a huge peer pressure one could not talk about Limbonic Art.
Perspective - just like talk about significance of Rotting Christ. Where I come from, EVERYBODY, and I say:
everybody, knew Rotting Christ. A lot of people appreciated it. If not overtly worshipped, they respected what it was about. Look at zines of the era, and striking and memorable Rotting Christ logo stands out in just about every second zine you put your hands to. Everybody knew Samael. Everybody knew Blasphemy, Beherit, Impalad Nazarene and such. Master's Hammer too. How can we measure what people
actually listened at their homes? No way to study it now. Indeed, I would say it would be matter of generation and the way how one approached metal, from where and under what circumstances. Significance of those type of bands is not merely "hype generated by forums". I would rather say that the actual fanbase may exists far far away from forums and genre social media.
For example, I was quite surprised to read Impaled Nazarene Suomi Finland Perkele has soon sold 90000 copies. So where are all the clone bands? Where are the tribute albums? Album so popular every year since it was published, it sells more than most new albums that came out.
A lot of bands in history of music do not get noticed for reason or another. Wrong time. Wrong label. Lack of will to even be more than they were. Whatever reason. Nevertheless, they may have enjoyed rather vast peer appreciation. Meaning of band not being in visible popularity, or door money of badly organized tour. Rather it's aura that shaped genre way more than one would think of.
Yet, if thinking what "popular" means:
Intended for or suited to the taste, understanding, or means of the general public rather than specialists or intellectuals. So, unpopularity certainly isn't bad quality! Or being unnoticed by masses, yet appreciated and cultivated by ... specialists?