Quote from: HONOR_IS_KING! on July 13, 2022, 07:11:12 PM
For Koufar one note I'd like to make clear. In the projects history only 2-3 releases have deeply personal lyrics, themes within them.
Link that was given, Koufar was indeed included in the 2nd category, "Socio-political" with comment of
often overlaps with 'personal' but with greater scope. I would think that is fair assessment of what lyrics are? Even when being about Lebasene history and culture, it is personal compared to lets say.... Genocide Organ dealing with topic they have picked? Neither is inferior, just different approach, in terms of how it is personal to creator.
Quote from: HONOR_IS_KING! on July 13, 2022, 07:11:12 PM
I guess the "realness" factor just comes from the simple reality that the topics all occurred according to history or are actively happening. "Realness" in that sense that my Grandfather has been captured on film numerous times shaking hands, giving kisses (like the italians kissing on the cheek) with Bachir Gemayel and his father Pierre who both are mentioned extensively throughout the discography and the collaboration with SHIFT being wholly dedicated to Pierre Gemayel.
The question of realness comes up once in a while, but seems like more often nowadays than before? I consider it trending approach of our times, as mainstream has already reached years ago level where actor sh/could not act something that he/she is not. Visiting the exhibition of youth artists while ago, had 80 artists, and dominating creations were in lines of my eating disorder, my body dysphoria, my mental illness, my medication, my identity, and so on. Like it or not, is kind of irrelevant, if we are just observing what would be currently prevailing or trending categories in art. Or social media. Comics. etc..
Realness factor is interesting in a way, that usually it tends to indicate implying something being more real. This is what I noticed in recent WCN episode where was mentioned that something that occurred in someones family as topic was more real than industrial/power electronics generally having "theme/study".
At certain age, people have usually experienced it all. All sorts of struggles, illness, death of loved ones, alienation from surroundings and so on. Some of it powerful and life altering experienced. Sometimes can be purely biological transformation what happens there. Personal and real. However, there are tons of things that have
occurred according to history or are actively happening, and to me it seems quite odd one would need to think its the artist family ties what make something real. As example: Lets say, I would make release about Finnish civil war or incidents related to WWII. How more real it becomes if I would report what my family went through, as opposed to dealing with these historical things from some other perspective? How much should listener know how these things had effect on people related to my bloodline? Regardless of that information, it would be all real, all factual. All having very real and physical effect to who I am, and how society turned out to be and so on.
In some cases I do appreciate the so called "getting your hands dirty" - first hand experience, but this leads to thing where I think we go more demanding area in art. Demand to see beyond what as viewer in current climate dominated by
personal is trained to see.
For example: In one hand you may expect "sex noise", to be personal in a way that you deal with what you know. Then people making remarks about lonely teenage virgins. Why? Couldn't it be just perfectly twisted and bizarre to have sex noise from lonely virgins, as it offers different angle to art. What is totally real there, might be realness of frustration, realness to pornographic addition, realness of unrealistic expectations and so on. It could be far more painful and dark, than some healthy report of personal functional sex life, haha...
Quote from: HONOR_IS_KING! on July 13, 2022, 07:11:12 PM
Also, been wanting me to bring up this point for sometimes but the fact is that SLOGUN is a project that is all those things you think detrimental to Industrial/PE, Mikko. A Project that is influenced heavily by his life, the streets, and hip hop culture (particularly graffiti). I still have Jon's performance notes from the final performance and in it Jon specifically writes, "do not look at the audience, make it about yourself," and also my favorite "I exist because of this". A whole lot of "ME" talk. Maybe needs a new thread, but frankly I think SLOGUN is that "real life" shit minus the albums he's done about serial killers. I don't think what SLOGUN has done is do any harm but open the door for others who want to explore that side of PE/Industrial which I think is valid as any other.
I don't object "me talk", if the
me is interesting. What Slogun deals with often, is things like self loathing, destructive, depressive things. You can approach that from looking mirror or looking out of the window. There are topics that are depicted to small, but expands into bigger thing.
I reject idea that
me or underlined
personal would be important or more "real" than other approaches in noise. Slogun certainly offered always new angle to power electronics. Nothing really is detrimental to power electronics, if it is fitting. I would guess some projects or artists having content drenched in delusional self importance and other such things could be touching very much same area as serial killers? Depending how you look at it. Not necessarily as interesting, though.
Urban decay of NYC certainly felt almost mythical back in the day, but certainly something where violent howling electronic racket fits perfectly.