Quote from: WCN on June 15, 2023, 02:06:00 PM
The context of this conversation was new methods for creating HARSH noise in its precise sense, whatever that may be, not general experimental sound. I can't provide an exact definition of that that is, but as a base definition I might personally say something like it is simply violent, loud, textured sound comprised of pure noise.
Oh yes, I feel this is kind of discussion of different "schools" of noise, what really constitutes as noise or harsh noise.
If we absolutely insist, that harsh noise must be: pure distortion - well, I guess in that sense we set so narrow limit to harsh noise that it can only be:
pure distortion. How that square wave of harsh distortion can be achieved, in the end, I would say there are very little room for advancement.
I would rather ask same question that I have asked any times before, is the
distortion the qualification of NOISE and harsh noise? I am not talking about experimental music as a whole. I am indeed, talking of Noise with capital N. Based on my own experience, where distortion and "harshness" may be equal to soothing bubble bath. That the noisiness, disorienting, challenging, confusing, surprising, unpleasant, sense of LOUDNESS, sense of decay, sense of damage, sense of brokenness, sense of disorganized chaos, and so forth, are also qualities of noise. Or more precisely HARSH noise. If some sound has only distortion, only texture, how harsh it is compared to something that has unexpected broken damage, decay, loudness (that is not depending on volume), and other qualities?
It feels odd, that if we'd want something new, and then limit the possibility of that required new into frame where nothing new could happen. Other than what method of distortion we will apply into sounds we have. I feel it is counterproductive to harsh noise, and neither it is harsh noise I personally know of. I'd rather say this is the
new noise. The late 2010's noise. New noise that thinks amount of static distortion is what defines its harshness, while you could grab something like Organum/TNB, Gerogerigege, S&Q (as easy examples we all know), who include the other qualities of
harsh (literal definition: unpleasantly rough or jarring to the senses, and furthermore, rough being literally "irregular surface; not smooth or level").
I am fully aware, this may be partly matter of semantics. But, that said, I am not talking about noise as "experimental music", but noise as sound that is not synonymous with sound you find from maximum settings of distortion pedal.